A Fitting Consolation

Why suffering needs more than an explanation (and how God gives us more)

Series: They Speak of Him: Seeing Jesus in the Old Testament
Preacher: Josh Allred
Date: November 8, 2026
Passage: Job 29-30
Listen: Audio & video on SermonAudio

AI-generated from the sermon transcript, human-reviewed

What do you need when the explanations run out?

In 1940, C.S. Lewis, arguably the greatest Christian apologist of the 20th century, described pain as God’s megaphone to rouse a deaf world. Lewis was no stranger to suffering. He lost his mother to cancer at the age of nine, endured the cruelty of an abusive headmaster, and served in the trenches of World War I, where he was wounded and lost close friends. His point was this: when we are deep in sin or error, much of the evil we engage in is masked by subtle deception. Pain, Lewis wrote, is unmasked evil. When we hurt, physically or emotionally, we know something is wrong. We cannot ignore it. It demands our attention, and it makes us ask questions about ourselves, our lives, and God.

Josh reminded us that Scripture gives several purposes for suffering. We may be under God’s loving discipline, as in Proverbs 3:11-12 and Hebrews 12:7. God may be refining us through trials, as in Romans 5:3-5 and James 1:2-4. Or we may ask what lesson we are meant to learn. But sometimes, as in Job’s case, those explanations do not quite fit. Sometimes suffering feels so out of proportion to any purpose we can see that no single explanation is enough. In those times, Josh said, we need something that goes further than an explanation. We need a consolation that fits our need.

Three Things to Know About Job

Before plunging into chapters 29 and 30, Josh laid out three things the opening of the book tells us.

First, Job is righteous. The text says so right away: “There was a man in the land of Uz whose name was Job, and that man was blameless and upright, one who feared God and turned away from evil” (1:1). We need to remember that, because throughout the book people keep telling Job he is in sin and must repent, and even Job feels as though God is punishing him. His righteousness was not merely private. He took on a priestly role for his children, rising early to offer burnt offerings in case they had “sinned and cursed God in their hearts” (1:5). And in the heavenly throne room, God goes further still: “Have you considered my servant Job, that there is none like him on the earth?” (1:8). Job is uniquely righteous on earth.

Second, cosmic evil exists in God’s world. The accuser has been going to and fro on the earth. Josh noted that the word Satan means accuser, a title that becomes a name across the Bible for the adversary of God and His people. He is not taking a stroll. As 1 Peter puts it, he prowls around like a roaring lion, seeking someone to devour. His accusation against Job is ready at hand: “Does Job fear God for no reason?” (1:9). It is an inside deal, he implies. Take away the blessings and Job will curse You to Your face. As Josh put it:

“Where God sees a servant, Satan sees a future apostate.”

This, Josh observed, is something Job’s friends seem to have no well-developed category for in their theology.

Third, God is sovereign and has His purposes. God is the one who brings Job up. He knows Job’s character, and He knows how Satan works. And the accuser can only touch what God allows: “only against him do not stretch out your hand” (1:12). Cosmic evil is at work in God’s world, but its boundaries are set by God Himself.

It is one thing to say all that in a neat, tidy sentence and move on. It is another thing, Josh said, “to feel thrown into the murky deep end of human suffering and try to see which way is up.” So he took us through three movements in Job 29 and 30:

  • Job’s Reversal
  • Job’s Anguish (or, if you want another R, the Result of his suffering)
  • Job’s Rescue

What Job Had

Job 29 opens Job’s last poetic speech in the book. It is his closing argument, a courtroom-style defense from a man who feels God is treating him as an enemy. And it begins with what he once had.

“Oh, that I were as in the months of old, as in the days when God watched over me, when his lamp shone upon my head, and by his light I walked through darkness.” (Job 29:2-3)

Notice where Job starts: the foundation of his flourishing was his relationship with God. He remembers God’s light, the friendship of God upon his tent, and his children around him.

From there (vv. 7-17), we see how Job’s walk with the Lord reflected God’s justice into his community, much like the description of God’s care for the needy in Psalm 146:5-9, read earlier in the service. City officials, the old, and the young all gave him honor, and the reason was his just treatment of the vulnerable: “because I delivered the poor who cried for help, and the fatherless who had none to help him. The blessing of him who was about to perish came upon me, and I caused the widow’s heart to sing for joy” (vv. 12-13).

Job clothed himself in righteousness and justice, but Josh stressed that this was “not aloof, above-you kind of righteousness.” It went out to people: “I was eyes to the blind and feet to the lame. I was a father to the needy, and I searched out the cause of him whom I did not know. I broke the fangs of the unrighteous and made him drop his prey from his teeth” (vv. 15-17).

The trajectory of such a life, Job thought, was a future of peace (vv. 18-25). He expected to die in his nest, an old man with roots spread out to the waters, his glory fresh and his bow ever new in his hand. He “lived like a king among his troops, like one who comforts mourners” (v. 25). His character, accomplishments, reputation, and prospects all seemed to converge on security and peace to the end of his days.

But that was before.

The Great Reversal

In the eyes of Job, his friends, and his community, God is now against him. Job cannot see why. Everyone else assumes either that Job was a fraud whom God is exposing, or that he was so deceived that God has taken up His cosmic megaphone to shake him out of the delusion that he is innocent. The tragedy, Josh said, is that we know better. We have been given part of the story that Job and the people around him do not have. God affirmed him in the heavenly court as a man of complete integrity, and far from being angry with him, God praised his devotion under Satan’s attempts to destroy him.

So Job 30 shows us a man treated as the opposite of what his character deserves, and the reversal touches every area Job described in chapter 29:

  • His honor becomes mockery. The one who sat as chief among his people is now laughed at by men “whose fathers I would have disdained to set with the dogs of my flock” (v. 1), outcasts from the margins of society (vv. 1-8).
  • His protection becomes siege. The mockery escalates to spitting, and then to attack, “as through a wide breach they come” (v. 14), like an army against a city whose walls have come down (vv. 9-15). Job even attributes their boldness to God: the bow that was once ever new in his hand, God has loosed its cord (v. 11).
  • His body is broken. Pain racks him to the bones (vv. 16-18). The righteousness and justice he once wore like a robe and turban now seem to choke him like a collar (v. 18).
  • His friendship with God seems turned to hostility. “God has cast me into the mire, and I have become like dust and ashes. I cry to you for help and you do not answer me; I stand, and you only look at me” (vv. 19-20).
  • His hope collapses into mourning (vv. 24-31).
“But when I hoped for good, evil came, and when I waited for light, darkness came.” (Job 30:26)
A Fitting Consolation

“But when I hoped for good, evil came, and when I waited for light, darkness came.”

Job 30:26

Josh said he was especially stricken by that verse. The man who once walked through darkness by God’s light now waits for light, and darkness comes. “My lyre is turned to mourning, and my pipe to the voice of those who weep” (v. 31).

Then he asked us to feel it. “This is your brother. He’s suffering. Is your heart not broken within you? Will somebody help him? Will somebody comfort him?”

When God Seems Absent or Hostile

Job’s suffering has distorted his view of God in two ways, Josh said. God seems absent or aloof, or God seems hostile.

Here Josh returned to C.S. Lewis. Lewis knew pain long before 1940, but the worst came later. As an old bachelor he unexpectedly found love and married the American writer Joy Davidman, and only four years later cancer took her. In his grief he filled four notebooks with his rawest thoughts. When he recovered, he thought someone in a similar place might benefit, but at first he was too ashamed to publish them under his own name. The book became A Grief Observed. In one of those early notebooks he wrote:

“Meanwhile, where is God? … Go to him when your need is desperate, when all other help is vain, and what do you find? A door slammed in your face, and a sound of bolting and double bolting on the inside. After that, silence.”

Those were not Lewis’s final words on God and suffering, Josh noted, but they were what he felt in that moment. Job’s speeches have the same rawness, sometimes getting close enough to blasphemy that we want to say, “Whoa, Job.” Yet he never curses God.

God can feel distant, aloof, as though He does not care. Or we may not say God doesn’t care, but we minimize our own suffering as too far beneath Him to matter. Or, as for Lewis, His presence simply seems withdrawn behind a locked door.

Or His presence can feel terrifying. Job has not become an atheist. He still believes God is righteous, holy, and mighty, and he gives beautiful descriptions of God’s power. But all of them have a dark edge for him, because he feels God’s justice against evil is aimed at him. He sees God as someone he must defend himself against. Josh asked whether we have ever felt something similar: someone who does not love God keeps getting the upper hand on you, and you wonder why God is allowing it.

So when the suffering is intense, when we cannot see the reason, and when God seems either absent or against us, what do we need? Sometimes, Josh said, explanations fail us. Even good theology can take on a dark edge from where we are standing. What goes beyond that is “a consolation that is fit for our suffering.”

Wasps and a Swing

Then Josh invited us to come up for air with a story. The first weekend after his son Jack was born, the family was at his in-laws’ for dinner. His daughter Ellie, two and a half, was strapped into a baby swing while his wife pushed her. Suddenly a swarm of wasps began buzzing around Ellie’s head. There was a nest no one knew about at the top of the A-frame, and the swing’s vibrations had disturbed it.

His wife, “in a beautiful display of heroism and maternal instinct,” plunged into the swarm and pulled Ellie out. Ellie was stung once, on her ear. Family members rushed in to check on her and comfort her. Meanwhile, her uncle David found the nest, pulled it down, smashed it, poured lighter fluid on it, and lit it on fire. Then he brought Ellie over and showed her how he had handled her enemy.

“That was a consolation fitting for her need.”

Consolation can look like plunging into the danger. It can look like tending wounds in the aftermath. And if something needs to be crushed and set on fire, it can look like that too. It is real rescue, Josh said, something you can remember when anything shaped like that danger rears its head again. Job needed that kind of consolation, and so do we.

Job Consoled and Restored

Thankfully, the speeches of Job and his friends end, because God shows up. He answers Job in a fitting way, addressing many of the concerns Job raised and correcting him where he needed correction. By Job 42, after God’s second speech, Job has made a complete turnaround from his dark view of God. He repents, and he is comforted in who God is, satisfied with God’s governance of creation and His administration of justice.

And Job is not merely consoled; he is restored. God vindicates his integrity, calling him “my servant” and placing him again in the role of mediator. God tells the friends He is angry with them and that they must ask Job to pray for them before He will accept their sacrifices. Job is no longer estranged from his community, and by God’s favor he receives double what he had before. Josh admitted he likes to think the ten children Job now has mean he was reconciled to his wife, and Scripture even lingers on the beauty and the names of his three new daughters.

But some things remain. Satan still goes to and fro on the earth. The Sabeans and Chaldeans who killed Job’s servants are still out there. And what about Job’s first ten children? We never learn their names.

Josh was careful here. He was not saying God’s answer was lacking. God gave Job the consolation fit for that moment in redemptive history. But Job’s pain brought to light a tension in God’s world that remains unresolved as the book ends, “a tension that anticipates a greater consolation.”

The Servant Who Dared

Back to Lewis. In the third notebook of A Grief Observed, the clouds begin to lift. Lewis reflects on the way we watch a loved one suffer and say, “If only I could bear it, or the worst of it, instead of her.” But no one can tell how seriously we mean that, because nothing is staked on it. Then Lewis writes that it was allowed to one, and that he can believe again that this One has done vicariously whatever can be so done.

We do need someone to take our place, Josh said, because our problem, and even Job’s, is not only the unmasked evil of pain. God’s megaphone is not just rousing us to ask what God will do about all the suffering out there.

C. S. Lewis imagines Jesus saying to us,
“You cannot and you dare not. I could and dared.”
“What about the evil in you? … We don’t just suffer. At times we inflict suffering. At times we are a source of suffering.”

“Come awake and see yourself rightly, sinner,” he pleaded, “because God will decisively do away with suffering, pain, and most importantly, the evil that is their source. Where will that leave you?”

God the Father put forward His servant Job to show that a man will worship God for God alone. He put forward another Servant to deal with another problem: His perfect Son, who entered a world that needs redeeming from suffering, sin, and death. And here Josh traced Job’s story onto the story of Christ:

  • By God’s light Job walked through darkness. The Son is the light that shines in the darkness, and the darkness has not overcome it.
  • Job was eyes to the blind and feet to the lame and wore righteousness like clothing. Jesus healed the blind and the lame, clothes us in His perfect righteousness, and satisfied God’s justice by wearing our sin.
  • Job expected a confident future of peace. Jesus came to establish a kingdom that cannot be shaken, but to get there He had to walk the darkest road any man has ever walked, and walk it alone.
  • Job did not know the cup of suffering he would drink. In the garden, Jesus knew exactly what was in that cup, and He still drank it.
  • Job was mocked and spat upon by outcasts. Jesus was despised and rejected, mocked, spat upon, and treated as a criminal despite His innocence.
  • Job’s body was racked with pain. Jesus was beaten, scourged, crowned with thorns, and crucified. He bore our griefs, carried our sorrows, and was pierced for our transgressions (Isaiah 53:4-5).
  • Job only believed God had turned against him. On the cross, God did turn against Christ. Jesus cried, “My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?” as He suffered the righteous wrath of God against our sin.
  • Job’s hope collapsed into mourning, but Job did not die. Jesus died, and His disciples watched their hopes collapse at the cross.

“I mourn for Job,” Josh said. “How much more should I mourn what they did to my Savior? And the saddest part is I share a part in that.” Only the God-man, Jesus Christ, could or would dare to stand in that place for us.

A Consolation More Than Fit

“He will wipe away every tear from their eyes, and death shall be no more, neither shall there be mourning, nor crying, nor pain anymore, for the former things have passed away.” (Revelation 21:4)

But that is not where the story ends. Jesus did not stay in the tomb. At Pentecost, Peter preached that God did not abandon Jesus to Hades, nor let His flesh see corruption. God raised Him up, loosing the pangs of death, “because it was not possible for him to be held by it,” and made this Jesus, crucified by lawless men, both Lord and Christ, exalted to His right hand (Acts 2). Our sin has been dealt with in His death and resurrection.

And what about all the death there ever was, and all the sorrow and pain? Part of the greatness of the consolation of the Christian story, Josh said, is that it is “not just about consolation. It’s about restoration.”

One thing Job learned from God’s speeches is that God sees the problem clearly and God is just. Here we see the same God intending to give us a consolation fit for our need: a new heaven and a new earth, with God dwelling among His people. In that world, Josh said, death, tears, mourning, and suffering will all be “untrue.”

And we cannot forget “that slippery serpent.” In Revelation 12:10-11, the accuser of our brothers is thrown down: “they have conquered him by the blood of the Lamb and by the word of their testimony.” The death we mourn has become victory. Just as Job refused to curse God, holding fast our testimony to Jesus Christ under trial is how we share in that victory.

Remember the wasps. God’s Son did not merely plunge into danger for us. He plunged into suffering and went to the very bottom of that well, into death itself, taking our sin with Him to nullify its claim on us. He came up having dealt a fatal blow to everything that separated us from God. Sin, death, and the devil have been decisively defeated, though we still face pain in this life. The resurrection is “a beacon of light, splitting the darkness forever,” a constant reminder that His resurrection, His victory, and His restoration will be ours, now in part and in full in the life to come.

Josh closed in prayer: “As we come up against suffering we may never have imagined we could walk through, Lord, suffering we would never choose, help us to remember the suffering you chose for us.”

If you are suffering today and no explanation seems to fit, you are not left with silence behind a bolted door. God has given a consolation more than fit for your need: His Son, who walked the darkest road alone, drank the cup, bore the wrath your sin deserves, and rose again. And if you have not yet turned from your sin to trust Him, the question Josh asked is for you: when God does away with evil for good, where will that leave you? Come to the One who could, and dared, take your place.

Find more sermon notes from Faith Covenant Church, or plan a Sunday visit to worship with us in Daytona Beach.

Highlights from the Message

  • “Sometimes our suffering can feel so out of proportion with whatever purposes God might have that it pushes us past any one explanation being enough.”
  • “Where God sees a servant, Satan sees a future apostate.”
  • “The accuser can only touch what God allows him to.”
  • “Job’s relationship with God is the foundation of his character and flourishing.”
  • “Job was a pillar of righteousness in his community, from the way he walked with God to the way he walked with his people.”
  • “This is your brother. He’s suffering. Is your heart not broken within you?”
  • “Sometimes explanations can fail us. And so what goes beyond that, I think, is a consolation that is fit for our suffering.”
  • “Consolation can look like plunging into the danger. It can look like tending wounds in the aftermath.”
  • “Job didn’t know the cup of suffering he was going to drink. In the garden, Jesus knew. He knew what was in that cup. And he still drank it.”
  • “Part of the greatness of the consolation of the Christian story is not just about consolation. It’s about restoration.”
  • “In Jesus Christ, God has given us a consolation more than fit for our need.”

Questions for Discussion

  1. How does believing someone’s suffering is a result of something they’ve done wrong hinder our ability to comfort them?
  2. Have you ever experienced a time when God seemed distant during suffering? What helped you through it?
  3. What does it look like to truly comfort someone who is suffering? How can we do that for one another?
  4. What aspect of Jesus entering our suffering comforts you in difficult times?
  5. What aspect of Christ’s return and the restoration of all things consoles you in this life?
Scroll to Top