The Bible's Great Dilemma

How God can justify the ungodly without becoming what He hates (and why that's good news)

Series: They Speak of Him: Seeing Jesus in the Old Testament
Preacher: Demetrius Williamson
Date: November 1, 2026
Passage: Proverbs 17:15
Lord’s Supper observed
Listen: Audio & video on SermonAudio

AI-generated from the sermon transcript, human-reviewed

What should the judge do?

Pastor Demetrius opened with a modern puzzle. Engineers designing self-driving cars have had to ask a hard question: should an autonomous car swerve to save five pedestrians if that means it will kill its one passenger? MIT called it “the moral machine” and surveyed millions of people about choices like that. Or think about Thanos in Avengers: Infinity War, whose twisted logic said the only way to save the world was to wipe out half of it.

That is a dilemma: a problem involving a difficult choice. Pastor Demetrius admitted that the dilemma in Proverbs 17:15 does not fit that definition exactly. God is not stuck choosing between two bad options. But this single verse highlights something “so true and at the heart of the gospel” that we must not miss it. It raises the question every sinner should ask: how can a holy God declare guilty people righteous and still be just?

Wisdom for Living Well

Before turning to the text, Pastor Demetrius offered some perspective on the book of Proverbs. Proverbs gives a general description of how we should live in everyday circumstances and how we develop character that pleases the Lord. It is full of wisdom, which is the art of living well in God’s world. And you cannot live well in God’s world if you do not acknowledge and submit to God. That is why Solomon begins with the fear of the Lord as the beginning of wisdom.

The Hebrew word for proverb, mashal, carries two likely meanings: “to rule” and “to be like.” A proverb, then, is a comparison drawn from life that teaches us what life is normally like. That matters, because most proverbs are not absolute promises. Proverbs 10:3 says, “The Lord does not let the righteous go hungry, but he thwarts the craving of the wicked.” Generally that is true, yet sometimes the righteous do starve and sometimes the wicked prosper.

But Pastor Demetrius argued that a handful of proverbs are absolute declarations. Proverbs 14:16 is one: “One who is wise is cautious and turns away from evil.” There is no situation where someone is truly wise and does not fear the Lord. Every time someone claims to be wise while embracing sin and folly, they prove the opposite.

He placed our text in that same rare category. Proverbs 17:15 is not a general observation. It is an absolute declaration about how God sees a certain kind of person.

A Verdict in the Courtroom

“He who justifies the wicked and he who condemns the righteous are both alike an abomination to the Lord.” (Proverbs 17:15)
The Bible's Great Dilemma

“He who justifies the wicked and he who condemns the righteous are both alike an abomination to the Lord.”

Proverbs 17:15

This proverb is meant to be visualized in a courtroom. It uses forensic, legal language. Picture a judge who has been given the responsibility to decide a case. All the evidence is laid before him, and it is point blank clear that one party is innocent and the other is guilty. Yet, contrary to all the evidence, he declares the innocent party guilty and the guilty party in the right.

So when we read “wicked” here, the word does carry a moral sense, but its main sense is legal: the wicked is the guilty party. Likewise, “righteous” here means the innocent party, the one who in light of all the testimony has done nothing wrong and ought to be declared in the right. The judge who flips those verdicts, God says, is an abomination.

Pastor Demetrius slowed down on that word. Guided by the Holy Spirit, Solomon reached for the strongest moral term possible. God declares definitively that such a person is morally reprehensible. That person has perverted justice, and God is “sick to his stomach, if you will.”

This was not new to Israel. In Exodus 23:6-8, Moses wrote, “You shall not pervert the justice due to your poor in his lawsuit. Keep far from a false charge, and do not kill the innocent and righteous, for I will not acquit the wicked. And you shall take no bribe, for a bribe blinds the clear-sighted and subverts the cause of those who are in the right.” Notice the legal terminology, and notice who is speaking: “I will not acquit the wicked.”

Why God Calls It an Abomination

Why does God take this so personally? Because He Himself is the Judge. He declares the guilty guilty and the innocent innocent. Every time a human judge declares the opposite of what God would declare, that judge is painting a false picture of God.

“Every time a human judge or individual who has been tasked to issue judgment in a case declares the opposite of what God would declare, that individual is an abomination to the Lord. That individual is painting a picture of God, which is not true.”

Pastor Demetrius named several more reasons this perversion offends the Lord.

  • It overturns God’s distinctions. Both acquitting the guilty and condemning the innocent subvert what God has declared to be good and evil.
  • It injures the innocent. The one wrongly declared guilty must now fight the temptation to stop living righteously: “If there is no justice, if I can’t be declared innocent, why live like this?”
  • It harms the guilty. The one wrongly acquitted is reinforced in wrongdoing, escapes the punishment he deserves, and gains a distorted view of God’s justice.
  • It harms society. When a culture declares evil good and good evil, it removes restraint from sinful hearts. “When there’s no consequence for your guilt, for your lawlessness, then that only encourages more lawlessness.”

Pastor Demetrius said our own culture is “turning into Exhibit A.” Not long ago it was unquestioned that killing an unborn child was murder. Now, he said, “we’ve scientified ourselves” into thinking life begins whenever we say it does, and the culture celebrates it. He also pointed to the promotion of bodily mutilation of minors under the term transitioning. Children who are confused and distraught need someone to come alongside them and say, “You ought not do this to yourself,” yet the culture celebrates it and treats those who speak against it as evil. “This is what the proverb condemns.”

And it happened in the Bible. It happened to Jesus. The religious leaders knew He was innocent and that not a single valid charge could convict Him, but they wanted Him dead, so they held a sham trial. Then Pilate declared numerous times that Jesus was innocent, yet to keep the peace he was willing to condemn the innocent. Proverbs 17:15 looks at Pilate and the religious leaders and says, “You are an abomination to the Lord.”

"Him Who Justifies the Ungodly"

Here is where the dilemma sharpens. If acquitting the guilty is an abomination, a careful reader might ask: isn’t that exactly what God does in the gospel? Doesn’t God declare the guilty righteous?

The apostle Paul deliberately presses on that tension in Romans 4:5:

“And to the one who does not work but believes in him who justifies the ungodly, his faith is counted as righteousness.” (Romans 4:5)

When Paul writes “who justifies the ungodly,” Pastor Demetrius explained, he is pointing his readers right back to the concept of Proverbs 17:15. He wants us to feel it: “Wait, wait, wait a minute.” How can God justify the ungodly? Wouldn’t He be violating His own law against perverting justice?

This is why the dilemma is not a choice between two difficult options. God does not pick between justifying the wicked and condemning the innocent so that He can show grace to sinners. In fact, if those were the only options on the table, the Lord would choose neither. “He would remain just and save no one.” God is just in Himself. He cannot violate justice without ceasing to be God.

“What God determines to do is to remain who he is, the just judge, while also condemning sin in his sinless son. That’s the gospel.”

Just and the Justifier

Pastor Demetrius took us to Romans 3:19-26. The law speaks so that “every mouth may be stopped, and the whole world may be held accountable to God.” By works of the law no human being will be justified in His sight. “But now the righteousness of God has been manifested apart from the law,” a righteousness that comes “through faith in Jesus Christ for all who believe.” All have sinned and fall short of the glory of God, and are “justified by his grace as a gift, through the redemption that is in Christ Jesus, whom God put forward as a propitiation by his blood, to be received by faith.”

“It was to show his righteousness at the present time, so that he might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.” (Romans 3:26)
The Bible's Great Dilemma

“It was to show his righteousness at the present time, so that he might be just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus.”

Romans 3:26

So this is what God does. He sends His Son in the likeness of sinful flesh. Jesus was not a sinner, but He came in human flesh so that God could condemn sin. On the cross a transaction took place: God laid on Jesus the guilt and shame of all His people. And because in that moment His Son was bearing sin, God justly punished Him. Jesus is condemned, innocent in Himself, yet bearing sin.

Pastor Demetrius drew out the beauty of it carefully:

  • The gospel is God’s refusal to be an abomination. He will not act contrary to who He is. He does not ignore our guilt. He deals with it in His Son.
  • God also deals with our lack of righteousness. If He only canceled past sins and then said, “Walk perfectly before Me,” we would be guilty again the moment we left the courtroom. Instead He gives to all who trust Jesus the righteousness of Christ, “like a cloak, a beautiful garment,” so we can stand before God on judgment day and not be condemned.

How do we receive this? Through faith. Justification comes after faith. Faith is the means by which we receive the declaration of righteousness, but it is not the basis of it. “Your faith in and of itself is not the reason you are declared righteous before God. Your faith connects you to the one who is righteous before God,” the One who lived sinlessly in your place, died under God’s anger in your place, and rose for your vindication. Faith is not a work. It is a heart posture that says for the first time, “I trust myself not at all. I trust Jesus.”

That is also why the claim that people can be justified apart from hearing of Jesus, simply by trying to serve a creator God they know from nature, is “an affront to the gospel.” If that were true, it would stamp out missions and evangelism, and the worst thing you could do would be to share the gospel with someone. “This is why we take the gospel to our neighbors and to the nations, because the only way an individual can be declared righteous in God’s sight is through faith in Jesus.”

Calling Evil Evil

The one who trusts Jesus, Pastor Demetrius said, has stopped living in a fantasy. One fantasy is believing that God will justify me apart from faith in Christ. Many people imagine that on the last day all they need to say is, “Lord, I’m sorry. Forgive me. Aren’t You more righteous than a human judge?” Without realizing it, “they want God to be an abomination. They want God to justify them without the punishment being meted out. And God won’t do that.”

The one who trusts Jesus also repents. The excuses end. “I have sinned against God and I deserve God’s wrath.” They call sin what it is, call evil evil, see Jesus as the righteous and good One, and acknowledge that God is righteous and just.

Proverbs 17:15 also has practical implications, both public and private. It applies not only to judges on the bench but to anyone deciding between two parties, two worldviews, or right and wrong. “If you find yourself in a situation where you’re looking at something and you’re like, I kind of believe that Scripture would have me acknowledge that this is wrong. But because I want to be empathetic, I won’t do so. You have violated Proverbs 17.”

Pastor Demetrius pointed to what our culture calls “toxic empathy”: detaching from truth, accountability, and justice in the name of someone’s well-being, while the true victim flounders under injustice. Feelings begin to outweigh facts. Concern is reserved for a preferred group. And justice is treated as the enemy of compassion. “But that’s not true. We can do it. We’re called to do it.”

Christians hold justice and compassion together by upholding the gospel. When we call out the killing of the innocent in the womb or the mutilation of children, we still offer hope and mercy through Christ. “We don’t set aside the truth. We preach it, we proclaim it, and then we offer them forgiveness in Christ.”

“The gospel offers real hope for real sinners.”

So, Saints, speak with courage and clarity to those who want you to believe evil is good and good is evil, and to those who want to silence you. And reflect God’s justice by refusing both favoritism and vengeance. God is ruling His world, and justice will be meted out perfectly. That frees believers from thinking, “I’ve got to get vengeance for myself because God won’t do it.”

Rest in Your Verdict

“Father God, I thank You so much for Your Word. I thank You that a seemingly simple proverb would point to the gospel. … I pray, God, that we would, by Your power, by Your Spirit, rejoice in this justification that we have.”

Pastor Demetrius closed with three words for the church. First, if you trust Jesus, God has declared you righteous in His sight. When you are in the throes of sin and begin to wonder whether this is the sin that will make God change His verdict, “this is when you need the doctrine of justification.” In Christ you are declared righteous, and “God will never renege on His forgiveness that He’s provided in Christ.”

Second, remind yourself that God is just and that His world is just, despite what you might feel in dark moments.

Third, we must safeguard the doctrine of justification. This is what Luther fought for, because he understood that if we lost justification by grace alone, through faith alone, in Christ alone, we lost the gospel.

And to anyone who does not yet trust Jesus, Pastor Demetrius made a direct appeal: “There is no declaration of righteousness and forgiveness outside of Him. You need God the Son to bear your sins in His body on the tree so that God can be the just justifier of your soul.” He closed in prayer.

Proverbs 17:15 tells us God will never call the guilty innocent. Romans tells us how, without breaking that word, He justifies the ungodly: He laid our guilt on His sinless Son and clothes all who trust Him in Christ’s righteousness. God is both just and the justifier of the one who has faith in Jesus. If you have not yet trusted Him, stop living in the fantasy that a simple “I’m sorry” will do. Turn from your sin and trust the One who was condemned in the place of sinners and raised for their vindication.

Highlights from the Message

  • “The fear of the Lord is the beginning of wisdom.”
  • “This proverb is meant to be visualized in the courtroom.”
  • “Every time a human judge or individual who has been tasked to issue judgment in a case declares the opposite of what God would declare, that individual is an abomination to the Lord. That individual is painting a picture of God, which is not true.”
  • “When there’s no consequence for your guilt, for your lawlessness, then that only encourages more lawlessness.”
  • “If that’s all God could do, either condemn the innocent or acquit the guilty, then the Lord would do neither. He would remain just and save no one.”
  • “What God determines to do is to remain who he is, the just judge, while also condemning sin in his sinless son. That’s the gospel.”
  • “The gospel is God’s refusal to be an abomination.”
  • “Your faith connects you to the one who is righteous before God.”
  • Those who think “Lord, forgive me” is all they need at the judgment “want God to be an abomination. They want God to justify them without the punishment being meted out.”
  • “The gospel offers real hope for real sinners.”
  • “God will never renege on His forgiveness that He’s provided in Christ.”

Questions for Discussion

  1. Are you confident that God has declared you “not guilty” in his sight forever? Did you do anything to deserve justification?
  2. Have you ever thought that God might be punishing you for past sins? How does the doctrine of justification help you deal with those feelings?
  3. In what ways might social media or group conversations tempt you to “justify the wicked” or “condemn the just”?
  4. Romans 4:5 says God “justifies the ungodly.” How is this different from the human “acquitting the guilty” that God detests in Proverbs 17:15? What makes God’s justification of sinners righteous rather than an abomination?
  5. How does the gospel empower you to pursue true justice—refusing to excuse the guilty or condemn the innocent—without becoming self-righteous or harsh?
Scroll to Top